Chapter 14: CH14: Fake out 18+
Eva had both her holes penetrated by her best friend and her boyfriend. "Fuck...she's getting tight!" Sterling gripped the bed with both Eva and Brenna's weight falling over him.
"That's what you get for calling me bitch!" Brenna grabbed Eva by her elbows and started thrusting her hips into her ass. Sterling waited to distinguish her movements. When she was thrusting out, Sterling thrusted in.
"Hooo..WWOOO...THAT'S...AMAZ....AAA...FUCK!"
Brenna and Sterling synchronised their movements fucking her in and out while Eva rolled her eyes upwards sticking her tongue out. "OOOOHHHHAAA....FUCK...I LOVE IT!" Eva screamed as both siblings explored her insides. Her body started sweating and soaked Sterling's abs.
"I never thought my first threesome would be with my sister!"
"Fuck her like that, baby! She's our bitch now!"
"You don't have to tell me, Bren! Grab her tight I'm going all out!" Sterling grabbed her thighs and moved his hips faster. "ARGHHHHNNN....AHHNNNNN...AHHHHNNN!" Eva's whole body broke with those thrusts. Brenna tried hard to match the pace but she couldn't.
With more grip inside her vagina and the stimulation given by Brenna, Eva was close to climax. Sterling understood her and thrusted his hips even deeper. "FUCK...YOU'RE BREAKING ME...AARGH!"
*thomb...thomb...thomb*
There was a noise of footsteps coming outside. Sterling recognised it and quickly called. "Brenna, hide mom's coming!"
"What?" Brenna didn't understand it. That's when she noticed the door was opening. She quickly pulled out and hid beneath her bed.
The door slid open to reveal Ophelia. Eva's face filled with satisfaction and embarrassment at the same time. Sterling was afraid of his mom finding Brenna being present in the room. "What are you two doing in Brenna's room?"
"Mom, Catherine was in my room. Brenna agreed to let us borrow her room!" Sterling came up with a lie to cover the truth.
Eva dropped on the bed and pulled Brenna's bedsheet to cover her body. That's when Ophelia saw Sterling's cock covered in both Eva's and his fluid.
"What is wrong with you, Sterling? You know what...Eva, get yourself cleaned and leave! You're not welcome here until I say so!"
"I would...argue but...his wood broke...my vocabulary...!" Eva struggled to put words.
"And you young man, you better come up with something to redeem yourself."
"I'll pay for Catherine's birthday party!"
"Wow...you are a good negotiator...no, I should be mad at you. You're not getting punished but this...is not happening again!"
Ophelia stormed off closing the door behind her, calling out Brenna on her way. Brenna crawled up and looked at her bed covered in the aftermath of what the three of them performed. "Why would you come up with a lie like that?"
"It's the best one I could come up with in the limited amount of time I had."
"And you, why didn't you lock the door?" Brenna yelled at Eva.
"Mmmnnnn...Sterling, our kids are adorable!" She was taking a nap.
"Bren, do you think we should tell her?" He eyed Eva.
"About Hunter?" Sterling nodded. "I don't think so! It's best if we keep it between us." Brenna removed her strap-on and put on her clothes. "Sterling, are you really going to pay for Catherine's birthday party?"
"I did have plans for it and to convince Mom, I have to!" Sterling approached her with his cum dripping from his cock.
"What are you doing?" Brenna was blushing as he got close to her.
"I know you're in a hurry because you're afraid but I think you should wait for a little longer. I want to give you the best first time."
"Stop making it so weird! It's just sex!"
"Between siblings, it's already weird." He grinned while Brenna chuckled. Sterling cupped her hands.
"I love you, Bren! One day, I will take your virginity! You don't have to be afraid of losing it to an old man with a dead meat. If he gets close to you, you are strong enough to defend yourself. So, don't be insecure! You and I are going to save this family?" He pulled her into a kiss, his right hand ran along her waist and grabbed her left buttcheek.
"So much for being vanilla, you horny son of a bitch!" She mouthed it over his lips. Sterling pecked her lips and said, "You just insulted your own mother!"
"So, incest jokes are going to be a thing between you two from now on?" Eva woke up rubbing her forehead. "I can't believe I passed out. That was intense." Eva looked around as the events came to her senses. "Oh my god...Ophelia caught us...again! I hate my life."
Sterling sighed and said. "Eva, don't worry about it! I'll get her to agree to have you around."
"My mother-in-law hates me, Sterling!"
"She is not your mother-in-law. You're not marrying my brother, woman!" Brenna yelled at her. Sterling put his clothes on in between their argument and went outside.
_________________
That evening, the doorbell rang. Sterling went to check the door. He opened it just to see his cousin Lucia waiting with her luggage. "Hello...wait...Sterling, is that you?"
"Yes indeed. I was expecting a warm hug from my favourite cousin."
"I'm your only cousin. You're not getting physical affection from me, dirtbag! Why didn't you call me while you were away? We could have run away together."
"And piss off Keira? I'm not doing that!"
"The best you get is two seconds of eye contact. Now take my luggage to your room. I'm going to take a shower."
She walked past him leaving her luggage. Sterling carried it upstairs while Lucia entered the living room to meet the others.
_______________
Lucia after taking her shower came outside wearing her towel. Unfortunately, she had to face the predator on her way. "Wooo...isn't it Keira's lovely daughter? I can't believe she was hiding this delicious food from me." Hunter got close to her and tried to grab her hands. Lucia observed him from top to bottom before pushing him away.
"I don't know who you are but you're Halloween costume isn't that scary!" She started walking away. "You'll have better luck getting in my pants if I was wearing some but I'm not interested in sleeping with someone like you!"
Hunter watched his prey get away from his grasp. 'Am I losing my touch? How did she figure it out that quickly?'
_______________
Lucia entered Sterling's room. Sterling was checking his laptop. Once he noticed her presence, he asked. "Do you want me to leave the room while you change?"
"What the hell are you talking about? We already saw each other naked. Whether you are here or not, it doesn't change anything to me."
"We were kids back then."
"Are you saying you might get aroused by my naked body!" She tilted her head to his side moving up her hips without realising that her posture just gave Sterling an erection. "Well, that just answered my question. Seriously, what's wrong with the people in this family?"
"What do you mean by people in this family?"
"Your grandfather was trying to seduce me in a decayed Halloween costume."
"He did what?" Sterling snapped. That's when Sterling realised something. Hunter could be Lucia's father or grandfather. "Luci, do you mind explaining what happened?" Lucia dropped her towel and started digging into her luggage. Sterling gulped and stared at her bare backside. "A warning would be nice, you know!"
"If you feel uncomfortable I don't care. I don't mind being naked around my best friend."
"Thanks for giving me the privilege. What did Hunter do?"
Lucia explained how she managed to find Hunter's intentions with her observation skills. Sterling was impressed by how she managed to avoid the disaster. Hunter slipped this one so Sterling thought bringing Lucia's expertise could benefit his hunt against Hunter. "Lucia, what I'm about to tell you could haunt you in your dreams. I'm concerned because I'm sleeping next to you." Lucia put her clothes on and sat next to her cousin. "He wasn't wearing a costume. That's what he looks like!"
"Ew...can't believe he made Ophelia!" She cringed. "You're sharing his blood. I hope it's not genetic."
"That's the thing. You might be related to him."
"I don't get it."
Then Sterling revealed the contents of his dad's notebook. Lucia was in shock after hearing that. Her whole body was immobilised for a moment. Stella shook her shoulders to bring her back to reality. "I'm sorry for dropping this bomb on you but you have to accept the reality."
Lucia looked at him deep in his eyes. It was strange for her. She'd never make eye contact with people for a longer period because of her disassociative disorder. "Lucia, you are scaring me! Say something!" She got up and turned around standing in front of Sterling before lowering herself on his lap. "What are you doing? I don't think it's appropriate!"
"Shut up! You left me alone in these people and now you came back just to tell me something like this? I have to beat this feeling with something worse."
"Lucia, what are you talking about?"
"Sterling, fuck me! You're going to fuck me like I'm a whore." Sterling was about to grab her hand but she flinched away and then repositioned herself. "I saw the way you looked at me. I didn't understand it then but after hearing about your family...our family history, I'm sure of it. You're also affected by the thrill of incest. Guess what! It is a disgusting feeling. But it will help me bear the truth about my birth.
Sterling didn't know what to do. He didn't like how the events turned out. Four years later, he met his cousin. She was his best friend. The only person she talked to freely without any remorse was Sterling. Right at that moment, his dick made the decision for him. It got even harder and popped out of his pants. "If we're doing this, then just look at me!"
"No, I don't want to look at you when I do this."
"If you don't look at me while I penetrate, it beats the purpose of us having sex. Remember, I want to have sex because I want to but you want to have sex because you don't want to. You don't want to have sex with me but you chose to so that you could feel something that can surpass the truth about Hunter. If you're not watching me having sex with you, I don't think it will be as effective."
Lucia turned around and thought. "Fine! We're not having sex!" She then left the room without saying anything else. Sterling stood there with blue balls. 'What was that? Was she messing with me? Oh my god, she pulled a prank on me for leaving without her! I'll get her back for that but first I have to take care of this guy! Sterling started masturbating. He didn't realise that his room wasn't locked. It opened slowly to reveal someone. Sterling was surprised that he didn't even though of covering his hard cock. The woman at his door entered and locked the door behind her. "Look what we got here! A hunk with a hard-on...do you want help with that big boy?"
Sterling started drooling at the cleavage of the woman in his room. She knelt down and touched his cock. "Fuck...is it happening? I can't believe it's happening."